Following
a stint in the United States Marine Corps, Harry E. Findel, following in his
father's footsteps, found civilian employment with the Long Island Railroad,
where he served as an engineer. Nothing
I have found even suggests that either his military or civilian service were
anything other than honorable.
Following
retirement, Harry and his wife Shirley moved to Florida.
Harry
died on September 18, 2013. And then, Shirley,
in her grief as she strived to deal with the adjustments necessitated by her
new condition of widowhood, received a disconcerting
letter from the Metropolitan Transportation Authority, the parent
organization of the LIRR. The letter
informed Shirley that a clerical error was made in 1995, resulting in Harry's
receiving a monthly $124.80 per month more than he should have been paid, and
will she please remit the accumulated $26,707.20 discrepancy back to the MTA
(which the MTA will be deign to extend the courtesy of allowing such repayments
through convenient deductions from her own widow's pension payments).
Comparing
the numbers on her reduced pension check with her living expenses, Shirley saw
that the arithmetic would not work for her, and so, she has
lawyered up and is contesting the MTA's determination.
The
MTA is claiming that it has the fiduciary duty to recoup the pension payments.
And,
quite frankly, they are correct. And
they should get the recoupment.
But
this recoupment, even if they recoup every penny, will come at a price.
As
mentioned in the posting of
31 July 2013, there was a big Railroad Retirement Board disability pension
fraud scandal involving LIRR employees. The last of the defendants have been sentenced. Some got some hard time in the pokey, but former
LIRR conductor Christopher
Parlante,
who gave a great operatic performance as he sang from the witness stand, was
spared the slammer for his own fraud, and ORDERED to repay his ill-gotten gain
of almost $295,000 at the rate of $25 per month. Doing the arithmetic, he should have it all
cleared in less than a thousand years.
The
comparison between Parlante and Shirley Findel is not lost on the widow or her
attorney. And the news media have not missed
that cruel irony either. Again, all
signals indicate that Harry Findel served honorably, and he does not seem to
have been implicated in this disability retirement scandal.
The
LIRR and MTA have been made into monkeys by the whole affair, as has the union,
which, as noted in the 31 July 2014 posting, gave free office space to Marie
Baran, the "consultant" who advised the LIRR retirees how to game the
system to claim false disability from the RRB.
The LIRR
is now at a labor contract impasse with its unions, who now threaten to strike
in July if the impasse is not resolved. I do not know how this one will play out, but
it would not be surprising in the least if this Parlante-Findel comparison is
somehow insinuated into the story line.
Labels: labor unions, Long Island Railroad, Pension fraud, Soft Judges, Widows
0 Comments:
Post a Comment
<< Home